Heaven Cakes!

The #1 Online Baking Resource

What Type Of Peanut Butter Is Best For Baking?

Hello,
I was just wondering if anyone knows what brand of peanut butter is best for baking cookies and fudges? I am using Jif but my cookies never really have a peanut butter flavor. I love peanut butter and want my baked goods to have that flavor. Can anyone help? Thanks
I usually do add more than the recipe asks... anything else i could try?

Sure.... Skippy Crunchy is my favorite to use. And I just add a bit more than the recipe calls for...you can do that and not ruin it, you know.

Categories: Best Baking
21 January 2010 at 12:21 - Comments
"O" FACE
Add more peanut butter?
References :
21 January 10 at 18:26
deedeetres
Sure…. Skippy Crunchy is my favorite to use. And I just add a bit more than the recipe calls for…you can do that and not ruin it, you know.
References :
21 January 10 at 18:37
carmen d
I make cookies during the holiday season and have found that cheaper is better for baking. I have tried many brands of peanut butter while making my filled peanut butter pop cookies and the more it costs the less I like the outcome. With some things the better brand is what you want but I feel that with peanut butter it is the exception. I hope that I have helped you in this matter. Good baking to you.
References :
21 January 10 at 19:22
cfnielson530
Oddly, I have found that the store brands of peanut butter have been the best. I always use creamy style.
References :
21 January 10 at 20:05
Polly
if u like it crunchy, crunchy peanut butter
if you like it smooth, smooth and creamy is the way to go .
add a small amount of chocolate in it , to bring flavor
x
References :
21 January 10 at 20:14
smartperson
I like using the freshly ground peanut butter you get from Whole Foods. Since it is made of only peanuts, you may need to add a little more oil to your recipe, but the fresh peanut flavor is great.
References :
Experience baking.
21 January 10 at 20:49
lucylocket7258
I’ve always had great results with the store brand. I haven’t ever seen the point of buying the more expensive name brand when the store brand gives you the same results…
References :
21 January 10 at 20:55